10 Big-Name Players That Arsenal Tried But Failed to Sign

​One of the most frustrating things you can endure as a supporter is hearing your side came this close to signing this player, then seeing them go on to achieve greatness elsewhere.

In the case of Arsenal, Arsene Wenger loved name dropping as much as DJ Khaled during his time in charge, constantly reminding fans about how they came within a whisker of signing so-and-so before they were big names in the football world.

During a ​Premier League era in which the club’s fans have been blessed with the likes of Sebastian Squillaci, Andre Santos, Marouane Chamakh and Yaya Sanogo, the following list will not only leave scars of their own, but add salt and lemon to the already gaping ones the above signings (and more) still leave.

Take a deep breath, ​Arsenal fans.

Virgil van Dijk

Celtic v Real Sociedad - Pre Season Friendly

Oh yes, this happened. Why, you ask? Because of nonchalance, apparently. Virgil van Dijk‘s sodding nonchalance.

“Arsenal’s chief scout [Steve Rowley] thought he was too nonchalant,” former Celtic assistant manager John Collins told beIN Sports. “Maybe that was part of his game but he ticks so many of the other boxes.

“He’s got pace, power, balance, distribution and he’s good in the air. He can be a bit nonchalant but he is a quality player.”

Oh for crying out loud.

Gerard Pique

Manchester United's Gerard Pique during

Looking to make a clean sweep of La Masia for three of its top players, Cesc Fabregas was the only one to come off in a trio that included Gerard Pique and one other player we’ll mention later.

Now firmly established as one of the best central defenders in the world, it could have been a completely different outlook in north London after Arsenal made a move to sign Pique. The Spaniard even went as far as visiting the club’s training facilities, but no move materialised.

It never quite worked out for him at ​Manchester United, but it could have been a different story in the capital.

Roberto Carlos

Robin Van Persie,Samir Nasri,Roberto Carlos

If you think this list is already painful enough, you just wait. 

When his time at ​Real Madrid was coming to an end, Roberto Carlos (very) openly admitted that a move to Arsenal was imminent, holding regular talks with Gilberto about what to expect in London.

How on God’s green earth this didn’t come to fruition and the only Brazilian left back to play for the club after that was Andre Santos, only Wenger will know.

Xabi Alonso

Real Madrid's new player Xabi Alonso tak

It’s the summer of 2009, Gareth Barry is Rafael Benitez’s first-choice signing (?!?) and it looks as if Xabi Alonso will be leaving. Regularly phoning close pal Fabregas and ‘begging’ to join the north London side, the Spaniard even headed to London to secure a £15m move.

Somewhere in the middle of all this, there is a hiccup. Not only does Alonso end up going to Madrid, but Barry doesn’t go to Anfield and the Gunners miss out.

They did sign Mikel Arteta, but Alonso? I know who I’d have picked at the time.

Vincent Kompany


One of the best defensive prospects in Europe available at a snip for £5m? Well, you’d be a fool not to, right?

Unless you find that fee too high, in which case it’s better to persist with the mediocrity that has plagued that position at Arsenal for an excruciatingly long period of time.

Yeah, Wenger didn’t fancy it. Hamburg did, then Manchester City did, and it all turned out pretty rosy for the Belgian and his employers after that.

Yaya Toure

Sticking with the ​City theme, one of the more memorable failings in Arsenal transfer policy history was a lack of patience with those troublesome work permits.

Actually taking part in a trial at the club against Barnet in 2003, the lack of urgency on the Gunners’ part to seal a work permit had Yaya Toure second-guessing the club’s faith in him. 

He opted to leave the side he was with, Beveren, and join the mighty Metalurh Donetsk instead. 

He could have been the Patrick Vieira successor.

Zlatan Ibrahimovic

Photo Shoot - Zlatan Ibrahimovic in Amsterdam

No matter how tired we’ve grown of Zlatan’s pigheadedness, it was the striker’s supreme confidence and arrogance that proved to be Arsenal’s undoing back in 2000. 

A £3m deal was agreed with Malmö FF to sign the promising forward, but after Wenger asked Zlatan to play in a trial match, the Swede replied: “Zlatan doesn’t do auditions’.

He may get on a few nerves, but I’m sure his goals would have more than made up for that.

Luis Suarez

Luis Suarez

Oh yes, this little gem. 

Totally convinced that ​Luis Suarez had a £40m release clause in his ​Liverpool contract, Arsenal saw it fit to submit an offer of £40m……and a penny. 

​As Wenger later revealed, this wasn’t to be the case. The Gunners were ‘wrongly advised’ that this was true, which prompted the Reds to reject the offer outright and owner John W. Henry to famously ponder what illegal, green herb was being consumed over in north London.

The Frenchman claimed that Arsenal had an agreement with the Uruguayan, but their lack of thorough research proved to be their undoing – and left them as the laughing stock of English football. Suarez later signed a new deal.

Cristiano Ronaldo

Cristano Ronaldo of Manchester United takes a drink

Here we go. If the above weren’t enough to send shivers down the spines of the club’s fans, the following two certainly will.

Before United had swooped in and convinced him of the project at Old Trafford, ​Cristiano Ronaldo had been shown around Arsenal by Wenger, who even went as far as handing the five-time Ballon d’Or winner his own shirt, completed with name on the back.

“But in the end it was a question of the transfer fee between the two clubs,” Wenger painfully ​admitted.

Which is a ludicrous claim when you consider he only cost roughly £12m. That summer, Arsenal bought Jose Antonio Reyes for £18m. They did go that season unbeaten, mind you, and Reyes played his part, so at least there was some consolation.

Lionel Messi

Leo Messi

Completing our trip down dreary lane is another one of the greatest players ever to have lived. Part of the aforementioned trio that included Fabregas and Pique was the Argentine star, although it was just a step too far for the Gunners. As we’ve seen with oh-so-many others.

Wenger confessed his interest and attempted move a few years after the deal never materialised, but conceded that ​Lionel Messi was ‘untouchable’ at the time.

It would be foolish to suggest that he’d have enjoyed a Thierry Henry-esque stint at Highbury, but for the few years that they could have held onto him, who knows what the club could have achieved.

Who knows, eh?

For more from Ross Kennerley, follow him on Twitter!  


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.